Prison Guard Killer Faces Execution Tonight
Huntsville
   
 
More Today's News:
ߦ   Galveston Resident Convicted of Two Child Pornography Charges
ߦ   Grand Jury Indicts Dallas Man on Multiple Charges of Child Exploitation
ߦ   Hebbronville Man Sentenced for Smuggling Drugs
ߦ   Houston Man Guilty of Drug Trafficking in East Texas
ߦ   Ogg Outlines Plans for "More Diversion, Less Jail" for Small-Time Offenders
ߦ   Paris Police Dept - Daily Arrests/Activity Summary
ߦ   Recovering Underage Victims of Sex Trafficking and Prostitution
ߦ   Santa Fe Man Sentenced to 60 Years for Aggravated Sexual Assault
ߦ   Sheriff’s Office Looking for Suspect in Numerous Car Burglaries and Thefts
ߦ   Sweet Surrender: Detroit-area man arrested with doughnuts
ߦ   Texas Man Indicted for “Sextorting” Minors in Illinois
ߦ   Texas Police Chief: If your business doesn’t want cops as customers, just let us know
ߦ   Two Indicted in Texas Wire Fraud Conspiracy
ߦ   Zapata Couple and Convicted Felons Sentenced on Firearms Charges
ߦ   “Horrific scene”: House fire kills 5 kids and adult, sheriff says
ߦ   Two Indicted in Eastern District of Texas Wire Fraud Conspiracy
ߦ   A Moment Every Lawman Fears
ߦ   Annual Texas Lone Star Rally - Nov. 3-5
ߦ   Atlanta woman put toddlers in oven, turned it on
ߦ   Authorities make final arrest in border agent's killing
ߦ   Coast Guard suspends search for missing man, continues to monitor oil platform after explosion
ߦ   Controversial exotic animal act set to return to Las Vegas
ߦ   Deputy who shot ex and killed himself was on duty, used service weapon
ߦ   DPS Offers Increased Reward, Seeks Leads in 1982 Travis County Murder
ߦ   Eight Men Arrested on Federal Child Sex Trafficking Charges
ߦ   FBI Releases 2016 Statistics for Law Enforcement Officers Killed and Assaulted in the Line of Duty
ߦ   Federal Court Shuts Down Houston Area Tax Return Preparers
ߦ   League City Police hosting a DEA Drug Take Back event
ߦ   Mexican Citizen Sentenced to 27 Years in Federal Prison for His Role in a Methamphetamine Distribution Conspiracy
ߦ   Reminder: Reward Increased to $8,000 for Most Wanted Sex Offender
ߦ   Serial killer called sheriff's office to confess
ߦ   Staggering Rise in Law Enforcement Officers Killed and Assaulted in The Line of Duty in 2016
ߦ   The show sadly goes on for ex-Ringling big cats in Europe
ߦ   Three Men Arrested on Extortion Charges For The Kidnapping of Two Men
ߦ   Virtual Kidnapping

 
Search Archives:
Robert Pruett faces his execution Thursday in the 1999 murder of a Texas prison guard. Pruett has consistently argued his innocence in the case, pushing for multiple rounds of DNA testing on crime scene evidence.
Robert Pruett was sentenced to death in 2002 for the murder of prison guard Daniel Nagle. Pruett says he was framed by corrupt guards and inmates while the prison employee union says chronic understaffing led to Nagle's murder.
BY JOLIE MCCULLOUGH OCT. 10, 2017 12 AM

A man convicted in the 1999 murder of a Texas prison guard faces execution Thursday for the sixth time in a case where DNA testing has taken center stage.

Robert Pruett was sentenced to death in the stabbing of Daniel Nagle, a 37-year-old guard at a prison in Beeville. Pruett was a 20-year-old inmate serving a 99-year sentence at the time for being an accomplice in a murder committed by his father when he was 15.

Nagle was found lying in a pool of blood, stabbed repeatedly with a makeshift knife next to a torn up disciplinary report he had written on Pruett, according to court records. The prosecution argued that Pruett killed Nagle in retaliation for the report, and the jury agreed, but Pruett has consistently denied his involvement in the crime. He said he was framed by corrupt guards and inmates, and his lawyers have argued against the testimony used at trial.

“The only supposed eyewitness testimony came from inmate informants. Such so-called snitch testimony is notoriously unreliable,” wrote attorney David Dow in Pruett’s latest filing to a federal appellate court.


For years, he has sought multiple rounds of DNA testing on clothes, the weapon and the torn-up report in an attempt to prove his innocence. It has saved him from execution multiple times since 2013.

But in April, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals finally ruled that the results of two rounds of DNA testing were inconclusive and therefore would not have changed the result of his conviction. A new execution date was set for Oct. 12.

“You’ve got to have faith in your juries and the many courts that have scrutinized the evidence and the claims here, and I just don’t see any room for there being a claim of innocence here,” said Jack Choate, executive director of the Special Prosecution Unit, which prosecutes Texas prison crimes.

Still, Pruett is fighting.

The Court of Criminal Appeals and U.S. Supreme Court denied his latest claims in state court last week, but he has also sued in federal court, claiming recent refusals by the trial court and prosecution to proceed with further DNA testing violates his due process rights.

The DNA evidence that was tested and deemed inconclusive by Texas’ high appellate court needs more examination, Pruett argues in court filings. The testing looked primarily at the murder weapon, where a partial female profile had been found in the latest examination.


Pruett argues that the court should further investigate the profile, to see if it could identify a culprit, but the state argued the weapon was likely contaminated by people on the defense team and journalists who have handled it without gloves since the trial. The court denied further testing.

“Even if there were contamination, that conclusion would only demonstrate that the State had violated another provision of state law by failing to ensure the weapon is properly preserved,” Dow wrote to the court.

Pruett’s latest federal appeal was rejected by the appellate court Friday, but he could still appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. Choate said that he expects the execution to proceed.

“I would be surprised to see the courts take a different position this late in the game,” he said.
Post a comment
Name/Nickname:
(required)
Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)
Comments: (plain text only)
Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
  Facebook   Share link on Twitter Tweet  
© 1999-2017 The Police News. All rights reserved.