Texas Police News.jpg



Astros thrown out of sign stealing suit brought by season ticket holders
More Today's News:
ߦ   14-year-old stepson of HPD sergeant found shot to death on Kingwood neighborhood walking trail
ߦ   Attorney Frederick McGuire sues another client for posting a bad review of him, seeks $1.2M in damages
ߦ   Judge admonished for telling man found guilty of murdering little girl that he should ‘die in a locked closet’
ߦ   Justices wipe $228,500 verdict against Cash America Pawn in malicious prosecution lawsuit
ߦ   Police union president blames judge for deadly shooting of HPD officer
ߦ   Texas judge slapped on the wrist for slapping stun cuffs on accused child predator and zapping him
ߦ   Texas judge warned after making racially charged social media posts, called Beto #fakemexican
ߦ   2 moms pull out guns during argument at Hazelwood elementary school
ߦ   31 miles of St. Louis highways to close Thursday for fallen Marine's funeral procession
ߦ   7 POWs Who Were Total Badasses After Being Taken Captive
ߦ   Body found floating in Brays Bayou in SE Houston
ߦ   Grapevine Police Media Manager Earns International Award
ߦ   Mo. Police Officer Killed in Fatal Shootout with Suspect
ߦ   Stolen U-Haul truck plunges into White Oak Bayou after police chase
ߦ   Student with cerebral palsy allegedly beaten on his birthday at school after argument, mom claims
ߦ   Texas judges order DA Kim Ogg to stop withholding Harding Street raid evidence - yet again
ߦ   Thousands of LAPD Employees to Ask for Vaccine Exemption
ߦ   ‘As Bad As It Gets’: Nebraska Judge Sentences Man to 52 Years for Repeatedly Hanging 2-Year-Old to Unconsciousness, Filming Abuse
ߦ   2 Florida middle schoolers arrested for allegedly plotting mass school shooting
ߦ   Apple’s App Store Dealt Blow by Judge in Epic Antitrust Case

Search Archives:

HOUSTON – Today, the 14th Court of Appeals dismissed a lawsuit against the Houston Astros – litigation brought by season ticket holders over the sign stealing scandal.

Back in February 2020, a class action was filed against the ball club alleging unjust enrichment. The Plaintiffs claimed that fans do not pay to seek crooked baseball games.

Court records show the Astros filed a Rule 91a motion to dismiss the litigation, arguing that the plaintiffs have no justiciable interest in a baseball game of a particular nature and quality and free from violations of MLB rules.

In other words, the plaintiffs cannot maintain a lawsuit for their disappointment over how the Astros played the game.

The trial court denied the Astros’ motion and an appeal ensued, court records show.

On appeal, the Astros argued that the plaintiffs’ claims based on the sign-stealing controversy are not legally recognized causes of action.

The plaintiffs maintained that their claims are based on statements off-the-field of falsely portraying the Astros as a team that has integrity, for example with its “Earn History” slogan, instead of a team that had been cheating for years.

The 14th Court found the trial court abused its discretion by denying the Astros’ motion, ordering the trial court to dismiss the plaintiffs’ claims.

“The plaintiffs claim that the Astros misrepresented how they played the game―that they played with integrity instead of cheating,” the opinion states. “In their consolidated petition, the plaintiffs expressed their disappointment and shame over the Astros’ stealing opposing teams’ signals. Claims based on how a sports team plays the game are not cognizable.

“Therefore, plaintiffs have not alleged legally cognizable claims on which they may recover damages. Furthermore, the plaintiffs cannot maintain their claims because they were only granted a revocable license to enter Minute Maid Park to watch the games in the seats for which they had purchased tickets and do not allege that they were denied those rights.”

The Hilliard Martinez Gonzales law firm in Corpus Christi represents the plaintiffs.

The Astros are represented by attorneys Reagan Simpson, Bryce Callahan and Grant Martinez.

Appeals case No. 14-20-00769-CV

Post a comment
Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)
Comments: (plain text only)
Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
© 1999-2021 The Police News. All rights reserved.