HOUSTON – Today, the 14th Court of Appeals dismissed a lawsuit
against the Houston Astros – litigation brought by season ticket holders
over the sign stealing scandal.
Back in February 2020,
a class action was filed against the ball club alleging unjust
enrichment. The Plaintiffs claimed that fans do not pay to seek crooked
Court records show the Astros filed a Rule 91a motion to dismiss
the litigation, arguing that the plaintiffs have no justiciable interest
in a baseball game of a particular nature and quality and free from
violations of MLB rules.
In other words, the plaintiffs cannot maintain a lawsuit for their disappointment over how the Astros played the game.
The trial court denied the Astros’ motion and an appeal ensued, court records show.
On appeal, the Astros argued that the plaintiffs’ claims based on
the sign-stealing controversy are not legally recognized causes of
The plaintiffs maintained that their claims are based on statements
off-the-field of falsely portraying the Astros as a team that has
integrity, for example with its “Earn History” slogan, instead of a team
that had been cheating for years.
The 14th Court found the trial court abused its discretion by
denying the Astros’ motion, ordering the trial court to dismiss the
“The plaintiffs claim that the Astros misrepresented how they
played the game―that they played with integrity instead of cheating,”
the opinion states. “In their consolidated petition, the plaintiffs
expressed their disappointment and shame over the Astros’ stealing
opposing teams’ signals. Claims based on how a sports team plays the
game are not cognizable.
“Therefore, plaintiffs have not alleged legally cognizable claims
on which they may recover damages. Furthermore, the plaintiffs cannot
maintain their claims because they were only granted a revocable license
to enter Minute Maid Park to watch the games in the seats for which
they had purchased tickets and do not allege that they were denied those
The Hilliard Martinez Gonzales law firm in Corpus Christi represents the plaintiffs.
The Astros are represented by attorneys Reagan Simpson, Bryce Callahan and Grant Martinez.
Appeals case No. 14-20-00769-CV