Texas Police News.jpg



Texas judges order DA Kim Ogg to stop withholding Harding Street raid evidence - yet again
More Today's News:
ߦ   Texas nurse convicted of killing 4 men with air injections
ߦ   Walmart hit with $27 million judgment for denying employee work breaks and overtime pay
ߦ   Woman struck, killed by car while checking on passenger on Katy Fwy, police say
ߦ   Chicago PD May Withhold Pensions From Cops Who Retire While Not Complying With Vaccine Mandate
ߦ   Conroe PD Investigates homicide
ߦ   Former Austin Officer Pens Scathing Response to City's Offer to Return
ߦ   NC Principal Apologizes for Letting Football Player Honor Fallen SRO with "Blue Lives" Flag
ߦ   Teen Charged With Austin Murder
ߦ   Texan who fled to Mexico gets life in prison for ambush murder of Houston security guard in 2015
ߦ   Texas jail offers $100 care packages to inmates who get vaccinated
ߦ   ‘A dangerous time’: Portland, Oregon, sees record homicides
ߦ   Colombian Businessman Charged with Money Laundering Extradited to the United States from Cabo Verde
ߦ   Former Security Services Executives Plead Guilty to Rigging Bids for Department of Defense Security Contracts
ߦ   Friendswood Police Activity Report October 12-18, 2021
ߦ   Grand jury might decide whether League City shooting was self-defense
ߦ   Husband's message to suspect who shot wife over $40 at bank ATM in SE Houston: 'Get a job'
ߦ   Loved ones on Harris County Pct. 4 deputy killed: 'He truly was, what a father is'
ߦ   One man killed, another injured in early-morning Galveston shooting
ߦ   Paris Police Dept. Activity Report
ߦ   Wharton County investigating couple found murdered in home

Search Archives:

The ruling from the state’s highest court Wednesday to Harris County prosecutors was definitive, and final: Turn the documents over.

For more than a year, Harris County prosecutors have fought requests from defense attorneys for information and evidence that are routinely turned over in every criminal case. The documents being sought are those used to charge some of the Houston police narcotics officers at the center of the Harding Street drug raid scandal.

After a 2019 drug raid ended in the deaths of two homeowners, Houston police investigators said the operation by Narcotics Squad 15 was based on lies by Gerald Goines, the veteran narcotics officer who led the operation.

The firefight led to investigations from the FBI, the Harris County District Attorney’s Office, and an internal probe by the police department. The FBI’s investigation led to federal charges against Goines — for violating the rights of the slain couple, Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas — and his former partner, Stephen Bryant, with lying on government documents.

Local prosecutors, meanwhile, began re-examining hundreds of cases Goines and his colleagues worked, dismissing many of them and pushing to have some convictions overturned. Ultimately, Goines was charged with felony murder, and a grand jury indicted him and 10 other current and former officers with a slew of other crimes, mostly related to lying on government documents to pad their overtime pay.

Harris County District Attorney Kim Ogg trumpeted the indictments in January, comparing the officers’ behavior to “straight-up graft,” which she said “can literally rot an institution from the inside out.”

At the time, defense attorneys representing several of the accused officers asked Ogg’s prosecutors for documents and information DA investigators used as the basis for the charges — documents they say they routinely receive in other cases.

Under the Michael Morton Act, prosecutors are required to share such information with defendants, but Ogg’s civil rights prosecutors have fought defense attorneys’ requests for the documents by arguing that they are protected from disclosure because they are work product.

The move has led to serious acrimony between defense attorneys and prosecutors, and even led a district judge to say last month that Ogg’s statements had “tainted” the public's view of the case.

The unanimous ruling from the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals follows similar requests by civil rights prosecutors in front of judges three other times over the past 13 months, a move that led local defense attorneys to accuse Ogg’s prosecutors of political prosecutions and prompted both the Harris County Criminal Lawyers Association and the Texas Criminal Defense Attorneys Association to file amicus briefs in support of the officers and urging release of the documents.

Defense attorneys reacted Wednesday by saying the court’s ruling was long overdue.

“It is pretty sad that the Harris County District Attorney’s Office, who, by law, is supposed to not seek a conviction but seek justice, will refuse to turn over an offense report that they know by law they have to,” said HCCLA President Joe Vinas, “and have to have judges at every level in the state tell them to do their job and prosecute cases fairly.”

Criminal defense attorney Ed McClees accused Ogg’s prosecutors of using “every trick they could think of” to withhold the documents he’d requested.

“I’m glad to see the Court of Criminal Appeals has put an end to their nonsense,” said McClees, who is representing Thomas Wood, a former Squad 15 member charged with aggregate theft and lying on government documents. “It flies in the face of Texas law and their ethical duties.”

On Wednesday, DA spokesman Dane Schiller downplayed the significance of the court ruling and said prosecutors would continue pursuing their case against Goines and the other accused officers.

“Prosecutors have a right to try to make their case to the court, defense attorneys make their case, and the court decides,” Schiller said. “And we respect that decision.”

Presiding Judge Sharon Keller and Judge Kevin Yeary filed a dissenting opinion, agreeing with Ogg’s prosecutors that the documents and information they seek to withhold was work product or exempted under the state’s code of criminal procedure.

“The trial court’s rationale for nevertheless requiring discovery is that the State, as opposed to a police department, was the investigating agency in this case,” Keller wrote, before arguing that prior rulings that prosecutors lose the work-product privilege if it investigates a case “has no basis in the law.”

But in one concurring opinion, judges David Newell, Barbara Hervey, Bert Richardson and Scott Walker argued that the materials Ogg’s attorneys were seeking to withhold “do not clearly fall within the recognized parameters of ‘work product,’” — and in a separate concurring opinion — noted that under the landmark Supreme Court case Brady vs. Maryland, prosecutors are specifically required to turn over exculpatory evidence to defendants.

“The work-product privilege is not absolute, and the duty to reveal exculpatory evidence as dictated by Brady overrides any privilege under the work-product doctrine,” wrote Newell, who worked at the Harris County District Attorney’s Office as an appellate prosecutor before being elected to the CCA.


Ogg is the worst DA Harris County has ever elected Nothing surprises me about her liberal leanings against police officers
Posted by LE at 9/16/2021 7:04:41 PM

Post a comment
Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)
Comments: (plain text only)
Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
© 1999-2021 The Police News. All rights reserved.