Texas Police News.jpg
Galco.jpg
                  

  


 

First Court reverses ruling denying H-E-B arbitration in injury suit
Houston
   
 
More Today's News:
ߦ   County looks to Sobering Center to house jail-diversion program
ߦ   Houston cop who struck and killed man with patrol car was driving at an unsafe speed, report details
ߦ   Houston trucker gets 110 years in prison for fatal Colorado pileup due to brake failure
ߦ   Man says he was threatened into smuggling $1M in crystal meth
ߦ   More South Florida officers died by COVID-19 than gunfire in the last two years
ߦ   Rolling Stones concert problems lead to push for disability task force
ߦ   Salvation Army official: Theft of toys no victory for Grinch
ߦ   Stabbing of rapper shuts down LA music festival
ߦ   Texas driver who killed cyclist on cross-country trek is charged, claimed he's 'blind in one eye'
ߦ   The driver shot by law enforcement is in critical condition after Polk Co. car chase
ߦ   Trial delayed for Texas officer who shot Black woman in home
ߦ   August Trial Set In $1M Suit Alleging Sonic Employee threw Drink On Woman
ߦ   FBI Releases 2020 Incident-Based (NIBRS) Data
ߦ   Galveston College Community Chorale sets holiday concert on Dec. 13
ߦ   Harris County approves $2.6M program to fight violent crime in unincorporated areas
ߦ   Harris County detention officer accused of encouraging and watching 8 inmates attack fellow inmate
ߦ   La Marque police increase night patrols to target crime hotspots
ߦ   Man arrested in hit-and-run that killed Dickinson teen
ߦ   Nursing Assistant Sentenced for Murdering Patients
ߦ   Texas law against Facebook and Twitter bans is blocked

 
Search Archives:

HOUSTON – The First Court of Appeals recently reversed a ruling denying H-E-B’s motion to compel arbitration in a personal injury lawsuit.

In 2019, Maria Saenz filed suit against H-E-B (Joe V’s Smart Shop), a nonsubscriber to Texas’ statutory workers’ compensation system, claiming the grocer’s negligence caused her workplace injury. 

While working as a baker for H-E-B, Saenz was struck by a forklift inside the store. Her injuries required back surgery.

Court records show that after Saenz filed suit, HEB moved to compel arbitration under the Work Injury Benefit Plan, which had Saenz’s electric signature.

In response to the motion to compel arbitration, Saenz asserted procedural unconscionability and provided an affidavit in which she averred that she does not read or write English and that she ordinarily relies on her children to translate for her.

She argued that she was pressured to electronically sign the documents in English and did not have time to review the documents or have them translated.

Court records show the trial court denied the motion to compel arbitration, stating on the record that it “found Ms. Saenz to be very credible.”

On appeal, H-E-B argued that it established that Saenz agreed to arbitrate disputes against HEB arising from on-the-job injuries and that her claims fall within the scope of that agreement, and that she failed to establish that her agreement to arbitrate is unenforceable due to procedural unconscionability.

On Oct. 12, the First Court held that Saenz did not demonstrate procedural unconscionability, reversing the trial court.

“HEB’s procedures are not a model of transparency and disclosure, and they can lead a new employee to unwittingly waive the right to a jury trial,” the opinion states. “Nonetheless, we are not presented with shocking evidence of fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, and we are bound by the policy determinations made by the Texas Supreme Court and the Texas Legislature.”

H-E-B is represented by San Antonio law firms Shelton & Valadez and Houston Dunn.

Saenz is represented in part by Roberts Markland.

Appeals case No. 01-20-00850-CV

Post a comment
Name/Nickname:
(required)
Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)
Comments: (plain text only)
Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
© 1999-2022 The Police News. All rights reserved.