Texas Police News.jpg
Galco.jpg
                  

  


 

Federal judge finds Houston company wasted insurer’s and taxpayers’ money by continuing suit
Houston
   
 
More Today's News:
ߦ   Killed over French bulldog: E. Harris Co. victim's mom believes killers may get away with murder
ߦ   Police News Links
ߦ   Prosecutor: Illinois cop was disarmed, killed with own gun
ߦ   Are e-bikes actually allowed on trails in Houston and Harris County?
ߦ   County looks to Sobering Center to house jail-diversion program
ߦ   Drew Peterson to ask judge to toss out murder conviction
ߦ   Illinois' law ending immigration detention in 2022 hits snag
ߦ   Mixed-use options considered for future of police HQ site downtown
ߦ   New Texas dog law combats cruelty
ߦ   Police funding, church tax breaks among new Texas laws taking effect Saturday
ߦ   Trailer Stolen From Galveston Driveway
ߦ   3 killed, 4 injured in major New Year's crash in northwest Harris County
ߦ   Deputy terminated after shooting 17-year-old suspect at NRG Park
ߦ   School Threat Arrest
ߦ   Woman shot and killed outside SW Houston hookah bar is city's first murder in 2022
ߦ   11-year-old girl shot while asleep in bed, Polk County deputies say
ߦ   Activity Report Dec 27
ߦ   Court losses for state complicate Virginia gambling rules
ߦ   Grapevine Police are looking for two children believed to have run away together
ߦ   Judge to consider bid to lower trucker's 110-year sentence

 
Search Archives:

Hughes
Judge Hughes

HOUSTON – A federal court was “not blind” to Cole & Ashcroft’s attempts to collect under two separate insurance policies because the company failed to document its damages, an opinion on summary judgment states.

Court records show Cole & Ashcroft, doing business as Shutters Plus, filed suit against State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company on Sept. 17, 2020, in Harris County District Court.

Cole & Ashcroft claims that a severe hailstorm damaged its property on May 9, 2019, and that State Auto performed “an insufficient” investigation, wrongfully underpaying its claim for damage to a metal roof.

Cole & Ashcroft then “was forced” to retain a public adjuster, National Public Adjusting, which returned an estimate of more than $700,000.

An appraisal award allowed for $388,892.70 in coverage and $57,257.98 in coverage for contents, court records show.

State Auto declined to make payment because it concluded the company’s damages were cosmetic in nature.

The suit was removed to federal court. State Auto moved for summary judgment and on July 8, 2021, U.S. District Judge Lynn Hughes signed a final judgment stating that Cole & Ashcroft take nothing from State Auto, court records show.

In Hughes’ opinion on summary judgment, the judge wrote that on Aug. 23, 2019, Cole & Ashcroft also sued Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, London over an insurance claim for damage to the same roof from Hurricane Harvey.

Cole & Ashcroft used the same public adjuster, who gave nearly identical estimates and the same expert, who highlighted much of the same damage as the case against State Auto, Hughes wrote.

The case against Lloyds settled in February 2020 for roughly $380,000.

Hughes found Cole & Ashcroft “offered little evidence” to support its claim against State Auto and spent “a majority of its briefing attacking” State Auto and its adjuster “rather than actually arguing facts.”

“The facts appear to suggest that Cole & Ashcroft was the party acting in bad faith. Nearly identical lawsuits – but for suing different insurers for different storms – were brought for nearly identical damage that was estimated by the same adjuster and supported by the same expert,” Hughes wrote. “The court is not blind to Cole & Ashcroft's attempts to collect under both policies because it failed to do its duty to separate and timely document its damages.

“Cole & Ashcroft collected what it needed to replace the roof yet continued to waste State Automobile's and the taxpayers' money by continuing this suit.”

Cole & Ashcroft was represented by McClenny Moseley & Associates.

Segal McCambridge Singer and Mahoney represented State Auto.

Case No. 4:20-cv-03507

Post a comment
Name/Nickname:
(required)
Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)
Comments: (plain text only)
Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
© 1999-2022 The Police News. All rights reserved.