Court sides with Houston in legal battle with firefighters
Houston
   
 
More Today's News:
ߦ   AG Paxton’s Child Exploitation Unit Arrests Austin Man for Possession of Child Pornography
ߦ   Coast Guard reopens Port of New Orleans
ߦ   Conroe Police Dept - Case Tracking Log
ߦ   DPS Seeks Leads in 1983 Cold Case from Galveston County
ߦ   Paris Police Dept - Daily Activity Summary
ߦ   13 mortifying mistakes cops make
ߦ   2 armed men rob donut shop and drag owner as he tried to get away: employee
ߦ   Baltimore police launch 'comeback story' recruitment campaign
ߦ   Bodycam footage shows suspect fight with officers before fatal OIS
ߦ   Corrections Officer Arrested for Not Performing Legally-Required Visual Inmate Checks
ߦ   Dave Smith: The Great Badge Eating Monster
ߦ   FBI investigating tattooed deputy gangs in LASD
ߦ   Grapevine Police Investigates Deadly Crash
ߦ   Officer Down: SWAT team, massive police response as off duty officer shot repeatedly
ߦ   Pilot dead after small plane crashes into community center building in west Harris County
ߦ   WATCH: Hiding Gunman Dead After Initiating Shoot-Out With Dallas Police
ߦ   Despite Ongoing Appeal, Execution Date Set For ‘Texas 7’ Inmate
ߦ   'Dog the Bounty Hunter' Star Leland Chapman Hospitalized on First Hunt Since Beth Chapman's Death
ߦ   Federal Judge Convicted Of Bribery
ߦ   Galveston Oilman Sentenced to 18 Years for Defrauding Investors

 
Search Archives:

HOUSTON -- The Texas 14th Court of Appeals affirmed June 20 the city of Houston’s and a number of city officials’ jurisdictional plea in the Houston Firefighters’ Relief and Retirement Fund’s lawsuit that alleged changes to the fund were unconstitutional.

The firefighters fund filed a lawsuit against the city and several of its officials, as well as the state of Texas, alleging new amendments to the fund via Senate Bill 2190 violate the Texas Constitution, specifically Article XVI, Section 67(f). It requested declaratory, injunctive and mandamus relief along with a financial judgment in its favor and attorney fees. However, the defendants had filed jurisdictional pleas, alleging the court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction, which were granted in a lower court, and the appeals court affirmed.

The appeals court first determined if the lower court erred when it greenlighted the city’s jurisdictional plea as the firefighters fund said SB 2190 is unconstitutional. 

The court said, “If the city is immune from suit under the doctrine of governmental immunity, courts lack subject-matter jurisdiction over the claims against the city.” While the fund said it determined a waiver for the city’s governmental immunity when it asked for declaratory judgment, the court said, “The city’s governmental immunity is waived only to the extent the fund has pleaded a viable constitutional claim…Thus, the fund’s request for a declaratory judgment that S.B. 2190 is unconstitutional is not enough to show a waiver of the city’s governmental immunity.”

The appeals court also answered the question of whether the firefighters fund has properly alleged that S.B. 2190 facially violates Section 67(f). It pointed out that simply showing a new regulation calls for unconstitutional actions just some of the time, isn’t sufficient. Instead, to prevail in claims that a statute is facially unconstitutional, it has to be unconstitutional in every situation, which isn’t the reality in this case, the court ruled.

The appeals court added that the lower court didn’t err when it granted the jurisdictional pleas, ruling, “[The] amendment could not cure the fund’s pleadings. Even so, the fund failed to request an opportunity to amend its pleadings in this regard after the trial court sustained the city’s jurisdictional plea.”

Chief Justice Kem Thompson Frost authored the opinion, and justices Charles A. Spain and Margaret “Meg” Poissant concurred.

Post a comment
Name/Nickname:
(required)
Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)
Comments: (plain text only)
Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
© 1999-2019 The Police News. All rights reserved.