Texas Police News.jpg
Galco.jpg
                  

  


 

Astros thrown out of sign stealing suit brought by season ticket holders
Houston
   
 
More Today's News:
ߦ   2 children, 2 adults killed after drunk driver crashes into golf cart in Galveston, police say
ߦ   Injured Hitchcock police officer shoots fleeing high-speed chase suspect, police say
ߦ   Hutto Police Department - Hiring Police Officers
ߦ   Texas A&M University - Galveston
ߦ   Recruiting? Contact Texas Police News For Help Recruiting!
ߦ   Alabama Execution of Joe Nathan James Marred by Failures to Set IV Line, Embarrassing Dress-Code Controversy, and Disrespect of Victim’s Family
ߦ   California State and Federal Courts Overturn Three Death Sentences
ߦ   Federal Appeals Court Finds South Carolina Judge Ignored Uncontested Evidence of Mental Illness, Reverses Death Sentence
ߦ   Former Oklahoma Governor and His Death Penalty Review Commission Co-Chair Call for Execution Halt
ߦ   Massive turnout for gun buyback event in Third Ward surprises city officials
ߦ   Reward offered for information leading to hit-and-run driver
ߦ   The Sun Can Kill You
ߦ   From The Archives
ߦ   AG Paxton Secures Important Victory in Fifth Circuit Against Imposing Harmful Mask-Mandates on Kids
ߦ   AG Paxton Supports SCOTUS Petition to Protect Jurors, Defend Federal Death Penalty Statute
ߦ   Armed Robber Arrested
ߦ   Death Notice - Retired Sgt. Oliver E. Brown - Retired 1991
ߦ   Deputy Uncovers Theft Ring
ߦ   Ex-cops Kueng, Thao sentenced for violating Floyd’s rights
ߦ   Hope Is Why We're Here - Remembering Adam John Walsh

   Next >>
 
Search Archives:

HOUSTON – Today, the 14th Court of Appeals dismissed a lawsuit against the Houston Astros – litigation brought by season ticket holders over the sign stealing scandal.

Back in February 2020, a class action was filed against the ball club alleging unjust enrichment. The Plaintiffs claimed that fans do not pay to seek crooked baseball games.

Court records show the Astros filed a Rule 91a motion to dismiss the litigation, arguing that the plaintiffs have no justiciable interest in a baseball game of a particular nature and quality and free from violations of MLB rules.

In other words, the plaintiffs cannot maintain a lawsuit for their disappointment over how the Astros played the game.

The trial court denied the Astros’ motion and an appeal ensued, court records show.

On appeal, the Astros argued that the plaintiffs’ claims based on the sign-stealing controversy are not legally recognized causes of action.

The plaintiffs maintained that their claims are based on statements off-the-field of falsely portraying the Astros as a team that has integrity, for example with its “Earn History” slogan, instead of a team that had been cheating for years.

The 14th Court found the trial court abused its discretion by denying the Astros’ motion, ordering the trial court to dismiss the plaintiffs’ claims.

“The plaintiffs claim that the Astros misrepresented how they played the game―that they played with integrity instead of cheating,” the opinion states. “In their consolidated petition, the plaintiffs expressed their disappointment and shame over the Astros’ stealing opposing teams’ signals. Claims based on how a sports team plays the game are not cognizable.

“Therefore, plaintiffs have not alleged legally cognizable claims on which they may recover damages. Furthermore, the plaintiffs cannot maintain their claims because they were only granted a revocable license to enter Minute Maid Park to watch the games in the seats for which they had purchased tickets and do not allege that they were denied those rights.”

The Hilliard Martinez Gonzales law firm in Corpus Christi represents the plaintiffs.

The Astros are represented by attorneys Reagan Simpson, Bryce Callahan and Grant Martinez.

Appeals case No. 14-20-00769-CV

Post a comment
Name/Nickname:
(required)
Email Address: (must be a valid address)
(will not be published or shared)
Comments: (plain text only)
Printer Friendly Format  Printer Friendly Format    Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend    RSS Feed  RSS Feed
© 1999-2022 The Police News. All rights reserved.